← Blog

Your Electricity Rate Is Only Part of What You're Paying

Your Electricity Rate Is Only Part of What You're Paying

I've been reviewing a lot of commercial and industrial electric accounts lately, and it's interesting how often the conversation starts with the supply rate.

I understand why. It's one of the more visible costs on an electricity bill, and in competitive markets, it's something customers can shop for.

But before recommending a procurement strategy, I generally want to understand what else is driving the bill.

Demand charges, transmission costs, utility rate classifications, and the timing of electricity consumption can all have a substantial influence on what a business pays. Depending on the facility, these costs can present opportunities that receive relatively little attention.

Understanding what you're paying for

Most electricity bills have two broad components: supply and delivery.

Supply generally covers the electricity purchased to serve the facility, along with certain wholesale market costs included in the supply price. In competitive markets, customers can often choose between utility default service and a third-party supplier.

Delivery covers the infrastructure and services needed to provide electricity to the customer. Depending on the utility and tariff, charges may include distribution, transmission, demand, and other regulated costs.

Changing electricity suppliers generally doesn't change the underlying utility delivery charges.

In September, New Hampshire Public Radio reported on rising electricity bills, including how delivery charges can account for nearly as much as supply for some customers.

For larger commercial and industrial facilities, the billing structure can be considerably more complicated. Different charges may depend on how much electricity is consumed, how quickly it is consumed, or when that consumption occurs.

Two facilities, same consumption, different costs

Most people are familiar with kilowatt-hours (kWh), the measure of electricity consumption.

Demand, measured in kilowatts (kW), represents the rate at which electricity is being used.

Many commercial and industrial utility tariffs include charges based on a facility's highest demand during a billing period, often measured over a 15-minute interval.

Consider two hypothetical facilities that each consume 100,000 kWh in a month.

Facility A operates relatively consistently and records a peak billing demand of 250 kW.

Facility B has more variable operations and records a peak billing demand of 400 kW.

At a demand charge of $15 per kW, Facility A would pay $3,750, while Facility B would pay $6,000.

That's $2,250 more in a single month, despite identical electricity consumption.

Actual tariffs can be more complicated, with multiple demand charges, minimums, or provisions that carry previous peaks into future billing periods.

When I see a high demand charge, one of the first things I want is interval data. The monthly bill tells us how high the demand reached, but it doesn't necessarily explain what caused it.

With 15-minute usage data, we can identify when the peaks occurred and start comparing them against facility operations. Was it a normal production period? Multiple pieces of equipment starting together? A seasonal process? Or something that happens infrequently?

Those details matter when deciding what, if anything, can reasonably be changed.

For some facilities, reducing peak demand may be as simple as adjusting equipment schedules or staggering large loads. Others may require equipment upgrades, controls, or operational changes.

Of course, those changes have to make sense. Disrupting production or affecting equipment performance to avoid a demand charge may cost more than it saves.

Understanding the cause of the peak gives us a much better starting point for evaluating the opportunity.

Sometimes the timing matters even more

A facility's highest monthly demand isn't necessarily the only peak that affects its costs.

Some transmission and capacity costs are influenced by how much electricity a customer uses during periods when the broader electrical system is experiencing high demand.

These are commonly referred to as coincident peaks, although the specific calculations and billing arrangements vary.

For example, a major component of New England's network transmission costs is allocated using demand during the hour when the applicable local transmission network reaches its monthly peak.

A facility's own highest-demand period might occur on a Tuesday morning, while the transmission network peaks on Thursday afternoon.

Those two events can affect different charges.

Depending on the tariff or supply agreement, system-related costs may appear separately, be incorporated into supply pricing, or be recovered through other billing mechanisms. Capacity-related charges can also use different peak calculations.

For facilities with significant exposure, understanding these arrangements can create opportunities to reduce costs by managing demand during critical periods.

Transmission costs are also worth watching as the region continues investing in infrastructure.

On November 16, ISO New England reported approximately $370 million in anticipated transmission reliability investments through 2030.

These projects are intended to maintain grid reliability, and qualifying investments can ultimately influence the transmission costs recovered from customers.

The practical question for a business is how those costs are allocated under its particular rate structure, and whether its operations provide any reasonable flexibility to manage them.

Are you on the right utility rate?

Another area I've been paying particular attention to is utility rate classification.

Utilities have different rate structures for different types and sizes of customers. Eligibility can depend on service voltage, demand, electrical configuration, and other requirements.

One rate might have relatively high demand charges and lower energy charges. Another might allocate those costs differently or include provisions better suited to certain operating profiles.

This becomes particularly important when a facility's operations have changed over time.

A business may have expanded, installed new equipment, changed operating schedules, or substantially altered its electricity demand since its utility account was established.

I've found it's worth looking at whether the current classification still fits how the facility operates today.

Evaluating the alternatives requires reviewing the applicable tariffs and modeling the facility's actual consumption and demand under each eligible rate.

Sometimes the existing classification remains the best choice. Other times, the difference can be substantial.

There's also a potential risk that deserves attention.

A customer may be receiving favorable treatment under a rate classification for which it no longer clearly meets the eligibility requirements. If the utility reviews that account, the customer could face a different and potentially more expensive billing structure.

Finding that situation may not produce immediate savings, but understanding the exposure gives the business an opportunity to plan for it.

Importantly, customers cannot simply select whichever rate appears cheapest. Eligibility requirements, historical demand, and other tariff provisions all need to be considered.

A relatively straightforward tariff review can sometimes identify meaningful savings, or an important financial risk, without changing how much electricity the facility uses.

Knowing where to look

There are other costs worth evaluating, depending on the customer.

Power factor, for example, can affect demand billing or create additional charges for facilities with substantial motor loads or other inductive equipment. Under the right circumstances, correction equipment can provide a reasonable financial return.

But the investment only makes sense if the utility's billing structure and the facility's electrical characteristics support it.

The same consideration applies to demand management, equipment scheduling, and other operational improvements.

For most businesses, twelve months of utility bills, the applicable tariff, and an understanding of facility operations provide a useful starting point. Interval data can then help explain when electricity is being used and what drives peak demand.

From there, we can quantify potential opportunities and evaluate them against the customer's operating requirements and financial objectives.

Some opportunities will be relatively straightforward. Others may require detailed engineering, coordination with the utility, or operational changes that simply aren't practical.

And sometimes the review confirms that the customer is already in a good position.

Procurement remains an important part of the evaluation. A well-structured supply agreement can deliver meaningful savings and reduce exposure to market volatility.

When I review an account, I want to understand what the business is paying, why those charges exist, and which factors are realistically within its control. That helps determine where the time and resources are best spent.

A competitive electricity rate can deliver meaningful savings, but understanding the full cost of electricity is what allows a business to identify where its greatest opportunities actually are.

Keep reading

Related posts